The 4% rule: where it came from, and when it breaks
The 4% rule says you can withdraw 4% of your portfolio in the first year of retirement, then raise that dollar amount with inflation each year, and expect the money to last about 30 years. On $1,000,000, that is $40,000 in year one. It comes from 1990s studies of US market history, not from a guarantee.
How does the 4% rule work?
The 4% applies once, to the balance on the day you retire. After that, the withdrawal follows inflation, not the market. On $1,000,000, year one is $40,000. If prices rise 3% that year, year two is $41,200, whether the portfolio rose or fell in between.
The common misreading is taking 4% of whatever the balance is each year. That version can’t run out, because it shrinks with the portfolio, but the income it pays can drop sharply after a bad year. The rule as studied keeps the income steady and lets the portfolio absorb the swings.
Where did 4% come from?
In October 1994, William Bengen tested withdrawal rates against US stock and bond returns from 1926 onward. A first-year withdrawal of 4%, raised for inflation, survived every 30-year period he tested; in no case did the money run out before 33 years (Bengen, 1994).
In 1998, three professors at Trinity University ran a similar test, and that paper became known as the Trinity study. For 30-year retirements from 1926 to 1995, a 4% inflation-adjusted withdrawal succeeded 95% of the time with all stocks, 98% with 75% stocks and 25% bonds, and 95% with half and half (Trinity study, Table 3). They concluded that rates of 3% to 4% gave high success rates for stock-heavy portfolios.
What does a withdrawal rate do to the target?
The rate turns yearly spending into a target: divide spending by the rate. For $50,000 a year:
| Withdrawal rate | Multiple of a year’s spending | Target |
|---|---|---|
| 4% | 25 | $1,250,000 |
| 3.5% | About 28.6 | $1,428,600 |
| 3% | About 33.3 | $1,666,700 |
Half a point looks small and moves the target by almost $180,000. The FIRE calculator shows the same for your own spending.
When does the 4% rule break?
- Longer retirements. The studies tested 30 years. Someone stopping at 40 may need the money to last 50. In the Trinity study, the same rate succeeded less often as the period lengthened.
- A bad start. Losses in the first years, while withdrawals continue, do more damage than the same losses later.
- Fees and taxes. The studies used market returns. Fund fees and taxes on withdrawals come out of the same money.
- A different portfolio. The results describe US stocks and bonds. A very cautious portfolio, or a very different market, needs its own numbers.
- Today’s prices. Morningstar’s 2025 research put the highest safe starting rate at 3.9%, for 30 years at a 90% probability of money left over, using a portfolio of 30% to 50% stocks (Morningstar).
How do people use it, then?
Mostly as a starting point. Some pick a lower rate for a longer retirement. Some plan to spend less after a poor year, which the studies didn’t assume. Either way, the target starts from yearly spending, which is the one input you can measure today. What is FIRE? covers the other numbers, and how to track your expenses covers that first one.
Sources
- William P. Bengen: Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data (Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994; FPA reprint). 4% lasted every 30-year period since 1926; no case ran out before 33 years
- AAII Journal: Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate That Is Sustainable (Cooley, Hubbard and Walz, February 1998). Table 3: success rates for each withdrawal rate, stock and bond mix and length of retirement, 1926 to 1995
- Morningstar: What’s a Safe Retirement Withdrawal Rate for 2026? (3 December 2025). 3.9% as the highest safe starting rate for 30 years at a 90% probability, in its 2025 research
This is an explanation, not advice about your money. TLDR Money is not a registered investment adviser and earns no commission on any product mentioned.
Where to go next
Questions
Is the 4% rule still valid?
It still describes what lasted 30 years in US market history. Morningstar’s 2025 research put the highest safe starting rate at 3.9% for a 30-year retirement, so current estimates sit close to it.
Does the 4% rule include taxes?
No. The original studies used market returns before fees and taxes. Taxes on withdrawals come out of the 4%.
Do I take 4% every year?
No. You take 4% of the starting balance in year one, then raise that dollar amount with inflation each year, whatever the portfolio does.
What about retirements longer than 30 years?
The studies tested up to 30 years. In the Trinity study, the same rate succeeded less often as the period lengthened, which is why early retirees often look at lower rates.
